Both sides previous revisionPrevious revisionNext revision | Previous revisionNext revisionBoth sides next revision |
authoring:cospwiki:outsidedocuments:liberal-articlev-disinfo [2015/10/15 08:35] – Oliver Wolcott | documents:answers:liberal-articlev-disinfo [2016/05/19 13:23] – Oliver Wolcott |
---|
| {{:documents:answers:wethepeople.png?nolink&500|}} |
<WRAP round download 60%> | <WRAP round download 60%> |
[[https://d3n8a8pro7vhmx.cloudfront.net/conventionofstates/pages/145/attachments/original/1430418730/Campaign-Against-Article-V_Natelson.pdf?1430418730|Download PDF]] | [[https://d3n8a8pro7vhmx.cloudfront.net/conventionofstates/pages/145/attachments/original/1430418730/Campaign-Against-Article-V_Natelson.pdf?1430418730|Download PDF]] |
| |
| |
| by Robert G. Natelson <sup>[[#i|(1)]]</sup> |
| |
by Robert G. Natelson <sup>[[#i|1]]</sup> | {{tag>Articles_of_Confederation con-con Congress Congress_count Necessary_and_Proper_Clause convention Constitutional_Convention Daily_Kos disinformation Eagle_Forum Eisenhower JBS Liberal_Establishment Earl_Warren 16th_amendment Natelson Reagan Scalia Robert_Kennedy Joseph_Tydings Earl_Warren Charles_Black Everett Dirksen Jacob_Javits William Proxmire William_Swindler Theodore_Sorensen Paul_Kauper Rovere Lawrence_Tribe Walter_Dellinger Gerald_Gunther Paul_Simon Warren_Burger Robert_Greenstein}} |
| |
=====Executive Summary===== | =====Executive Summary===== |
| |
*Little is known about how the process is supposed to operate; | *Little is known about how the process is supposed to operate; |
*a convention for proposing amendments would be an uncontrollable "constitutional convention;" | *a convention for proposing amendments would be an uncontrollable "constitutional convention;" |
*a convention for proposing amendments could be controlled or manipulated by Congress under the Constitution's Necessary and Proper Clause;<sup>[[#iii|3]]</sup> and | *a convention for proposing amendments could be controlled or manipulated by Congress under the Constitution's Necessary and Proper Clause;<sup>[[#iii|(3)]]</sup> and |
*a convention for proposing amendments could unilaterally impose radical constitutional changes on America. | *a convention for proposing amendments could unilaterally impose radical constitutional changes on America. |
| |
<BOOKMARK:xxix>29. Lawrence H. Tribe, Issues Raised by Requesting Congress to Call a Constitutional Convention to Propose a Balanced Budget Amendment, 10 Pac.L.J. 627 (1979). | <BOOKMARK:xxix>29. Lawrence H. Tribe, Issues Raised by Requesting Congress to Call a Constitutional Convention to Propose a Balanced Budget Amendment, 10 Pac.L.J. 627 (1979). |
| |
<BOOKMARK:xxx>30. Robert G. Natelson, [[authoring:cospwiki:outsidedocuments:articlev-handbook#answers_to_criticisms|The Article V Handbook 33-35]] (2d ed., 2013). | <BOOKMARK:xxx>30. Robert G. Natelson, [[documents:external:articlev-handbook#answers_to_criticisms|The Article V Handbook 33-35]] (2d ed., 2013). |
| |
<BOOKMARK:xxxi>31. See, e.g., [[http://www.eagleforum.org/alert/2011/pdf/20Questions.pdf|http://www.eagleforum.org/alert/2011/pdf/20Questions.pdf]] . | <BOOKMARK:xxxi>31. See, e.g., [[http://www.eagleforum.org/alert/2011/pdf/20Questions.pdf|http://www.eagleforum.org/alert/2011/pdf/20Questions.pdf]] . |